NEW – RHS Toolbox version 2: River Condition Assessment, citizen RHS, RCA and Greek river typologies and an online database

RHS Toolbox version 2 is out. It is the biggest update since the software was first released, and the first public release of version 2. Some of you will have seen it mentioned in last year’s post on Greek rivers, where it was described as “not yet available”. It now is.

The new version adds:

  • the River Condition Assessment (RCA) used in England’s Biodiversity Net Gain, calculated from RHS data
  • data entry, quality control and indices for the Citizen River Habitat Survey (cRHS), and the upgrade of citizen surveys to cRHS plus
  • the Greek river typology, so HQA scores of Greek rivers can be compared with sites of the same type
  • an online platform and map for sharing RHS and cRHS data, photos, videos and 360° photos
  • a data analysis tab, an improved context analysis and new indices: width/depth ratio, a Channel Resectioning Index, and bank and riparian vegetation naturalness for RHS with Phase 1 surveys

Version 2 was developed with the support of Natural Resources Wales and in collaboration with the River Restoration Centre (RRC). Everything you know from version 1.5 is still there: RHS data input, quality control, HQA, HMS, RHQ, RQI, the hydromorphological indices and impact ratios, RHAT, and imports from RHS Mobile and RAPID. The full list of changes is on the What’s new page of the online help.

River Condition Assessment from RHS data

The Toolbox can now estimate the condition of any RHS site in your database using the River Condition Assessment (Gurnell et al., 2020). This is the method behind the river condition scores in the Statutory Biodiversity Metric for Biodiversity Net Gain. It scores positive features, such as vegetation structure, natural bank profiles and varied bed material, and negative ones, such as reinforcement, artificial structures, invasive plants and siltation. It looks at four zones: bank top, bank face, channel margin and channel bed.

The RCA was designed for MoRPh surveys. The Toolbox applies the same river typology, indicators and thresholds to RHS data:

  1. Desk-study indicators. Sinuosity, valley gradient and the other desk-study indicators are filled from map data and the RHS survey. Values you type in are never overwritten.
  2. River type. Bed-material indicators come from the recorded substrate and the predicted semi-natural substrate, so a modified bed does not change the river type. The RCA decision tree then suggests a type, which you can accept or change.
  3. 32 condition indicators. The spot-checks are grouped into five “pseudo-modules” to match MoRPh, sweep-up data fill the gaps, and feature counts can be rescaled to MoRPh survey length.
  4. Score and class. The Toolbox calculates the Preliminary Condition Score and the Final Condition Class, from Poor to Good, adjusted for over-deepened channels as the RCA guide sets out. Each calculation adds a dated record to the site comments.
The River Condition Assessment page of the RHS Toolbox
The River Condition Assessment page.

The results are RHS-based estimates of the RCA, not a MoRPh survey. Until recently, RCA outputs for BNG were produced with the Cartographer platform, but the Planning Advisory Service’s Deep Dive into Watercourses and BNG, reviewed by the Environment Agency, now states that using Cartographer is not mandatory. Ecologists may produce their own RCA outputs by applying the published, open-access RCA scores (Gurnell et al., 2020), which is what the Toolbox does. That page is advice to local planning authorities, not Government policy, and neither Natural England nor the Environment Agency has yet said whether survey methods other than MoRPh, such as RHS, are acceptable. Check the current Biodiversity Metric User Guide and with your local planning authority before using RHS-based scores in a BNG assessment.

In the meantime, the module makes it possible to look at river condition across existing RHS datasets, and to compare it with HQA, HMS, RHQ and the other RHS indices. We have done this for about 200 sites and will report the results in a separate post.

The step-by-step guide is on the River Condition Assessment help page, and Appendix 5 explains how each indicator is derived from RHS.

Citizen River Habitat Survey (cRHS)

The Citizen River Habitat Survey is a simplified RHS for volunteers and non-specialists. With a short training, they record about 75% of an RHS form along the usual 500 m site, and film every spot-check. They can also take 360° photos along the site.

cRHS is a learning process: citizen surveyors, the RHS Toolbox, the online database and map, and expert RHS surveyors

Version 2 has a dedicated cRHS data input form, with quality control and index calculation. It also imports data, photo and video links from the cRHS Android app.

The cRHS data input form
The cRHS data input form.

From cRHS to cRHS plus

A citizen survey can be upgraded by an experienced RHS surveyor. Using the videos and photos, and talking to the citizen surveyor, they can add up to 15% more information. That is enough to calculate all the RHS quality indices and compare the site with similar sites.

The upgrade works through the online platform and map:

  1. The citizen surveyor uploads their survey, with open or restricted access.
  2. A reviewer downloads it, opens it as a full RHS form and completes it. A cRHS Review tab lets the reviewer and the surveyor exchange messages.
  3. The reviewer uploads the upgraded survey, which is marked as cRHS plus on the online map.
  4. The citizen surveyor downloads the upgraded version to their PC.

Reviewer status is given by the River Restoration Centre team to experienced, certified RHS surveyors. The process is described in the cRHS upgrade help page.

There is free cRHS training online on the RRC training platform.

A cRHS plus site on the online map, with its quality classes and links to photos, videos, 360° photos and a summary report
A cRHS plus site on the online map.

Greek river typology

HQA scores only make sense when a site is compared with sites of a similar type. The Toolbox does this through a context analysis against a national baseline survey. Until now, those baselines covered only the UK and Ireland.

The Institute of Marine Biological Research and Inland Waters (IMBRIW) surveyed more than 300 Greek river sites with RHS. Their data are now built into the Toolbox as a baseline survey for Greece. Allocate a Greek river type to your site in the map data tab, and the context analysis compares it with Greek sites of the same type. This work is described in the post Expanding the Habitat Quality Assessment of Rivers in Greece and in the published study.

Baseline surveys available in the context analysis, now including Greece
Baseline surveys available in the context analysis, now including Greece.

The context analysis itself has also improved. As well as the median for sites of similar type, it now shows the HQA score and sub-scores of the top 20% of sites. You can see where your site falls short of the best sites of its type, for example in channel vegetation or flow types.

The context analysis module, comparing a site with the median and top 20% of 150 sites of similar type
The context analysis compares your site with the median and the top 20% of sites of similar type.

If you hold a national RHS dataset and would like type-specific HQA classes for your country, please get in touch.

Online platform and map

We developed an online platform for RHS and cRHS with Natural Resources Wales and the RRC. It hosts cRHS learning material, a free online cRHS course, forms, the manual and a map of RHS and cRHS sites.

From the export menu, the Toolbox sends a survey online with its georeferenced photos, videos and 360° photos. Only surveys that pass quality control and have all indices calculated can be uploaded. Each site gets a permanent site number. On the map, it shows its quality classes, photos, videos, a virtual walk built from the 360° photos and a summary report. Before uploading, you agree to make the data and photos publicly available under a Creative Commons-based agreement.

The RHS and cRHS online map
The RHS and cRHS online map.
From the Toolbox to the online map: site summary, report, videos and 360° virtual walk
Each uploaded site links to its summary report, photos, videos and a 360° virtual walk.

See Export online to the cRHS/RHS platform in the help for details.

Data analysis tab

The RHS and cRHS forms have a new data analysis tab. Once all indices and a River Habitat Quality class are calculated, it gives a short report on the site’s habitat quality. It points out likely modifications, such as channel resectioning based on width and depth, and links to the RRC’s Manual of River Restoration Techniques and case studies. The report is also included in the survey printout.

The data analysis tab of the cRHS form
The data analysis tab.

Getting RHS Toolbox 2

You can download the RHS Toolbox and try it free for 30 days. It runs on Windows 8 to 11 with Microsoft Access 2013 or later. If you do not have Access, the installer offers a free Access runtime. See the system requirements.

After the trial, a yearly licence unlocks the advanced features:

  • Business and public sector: £100 per year
  • Charity, not-for-profit and self-employed: £70 per year
  • Student: £30 per year

Licences can be bought from the Riverdene Consultancy website. If your organisation needs several users, please contact us. The full online help covers installation, licence activation and every module.

Many thanks to Natural Resources Wales, the River Restoration Centre and IMBRIW for their support. As always, we welcome your comments and suggestions for future versions.

Expanding the Habitat Quality Assessment of Rivers in Greece

By Kostas Stefanidis (1)

Historically, Greece lacked a unified, integrated approach for assessing the hydromorphological quality of its rivers. This gap became particularly evident when the European Union’s Water Framework Directive (WFD) required member states to monitor the hydromorphological status of all surface freshwater bodies systematically.

In response, our team from the Institute of Marine Biological Research and Inland Waters (IMBRIW), applied the River Habitat Survey in more than 300 river sites collecting information on a wide range of channel and bank features and recording various types of modifications and changes in the physical characteristics of rivers and streams. Although calculations of the Habitat Modification Score (HMS) were already feasible based on the existing information, Habitat Quality Assessments required a context analysis for comparing habitat features between sites of similar types.

In our recently published study, we integrated data from the Greek monitoring program into the RHS toolbox (version 2, not yet available) resulting to a new updated version that allows for type-specific assessments using the Habitat Quality Assessment (HQA) score. We specifically used data collected from 366 monitoring sites across Greece, representing a diverse range of river types and environmental conditions. This extensive dataset allowed for a comprehensive analysis of habitat quality across the country and for the first time since the implementation of the WFD in Greece, a classification of the hydromorphological quality of Greek rivers was achieved.

The findings of our study revealed significant spatial patterns in habitat quality, with variations linked to factors such as altitude, land cover, and regional differences. For instance, rivers in mid and high-altitude catchments with natural land cover generally had better HQA scores compared to lowland rivers surrounded by agricultural or urban landscapes. Specifically, rivers located in mid and high-altitude areas, especially those surrounded by forests or natural vegetation, displayed higher HQA scores. These areas are often less impacted by human activities, allowing for better-preserved river habitats. In contrast, lowland rivers, particularly those in agricultural regions, showed lower HQA scores. The intensive land use associated with agriculture often leads to increased sedimentation, nutrient runoff, and habitat degradation. Urbanized regions, such as the densely populated Attica district and parts of central Greece, exhibited lower habitat quality. The pressures of urban development, including pollution, altered flow regimes, and habitat fragmentation, were evident in these areas.

In addition to assessing physical habitat quality, we also explored the relationship between habitat quality and biological quality indices. We used the Ecological Quality Ratios (EQRs) for three biological quality elements: benthic diatoms, benthic macroinvertebrates, and fish. These elements are critical indicators of ecological health, as they respond sensitively to changes in water quality and habitat conditions.

Our results indicated significant correlations between HQA scores and EQR values, particularly for small and medium lowland streams. Sites with higher habitat quality tended to support healthier biological communities, emphasizing the importance of preserving and restoring physical habitat conditions to maintain ecological integrity.

The implications of our study for river management in Greece are profound. By providing a comprehensive assessment of habitat quality across the country, we have established a baseline for future monitoring efforts. The identification of regions and river types most at risk of degradation offers valuable guidance for targeted conservation and restoration initiatives.

Moreover, the study underscores the importance of integrating hydromorphological and biological assessments. The correlations between habitat quality and EQR values highlight the linkages between physical and biological aspects of river ecosystems. Effective river management must consider both elements to ensure the long-term health and sustainability of freshwater resources.

In conclusion, the study by the team of IMBRIW represents a milestone in the assessment of river habitats in Greece. By expanding the application of the RHS toolbox to a national scale, we demonstrated the value of a standardized, nationwide approach to habitat quality assessment, providing a model that can be adapted and expanded in the future.

However, the work is far from complete. Ongoing monitoring and research are essential to track changes in habitat quality over time, particularly in the face of increasing pressures from climate change, land use, and urbanization. The updated RHS toolbox, with its ability to provide detailed, site-specific assessments, will be an invaluable tool in this ongoing effort.

(1) Institute of Marine Biological Resources and Inland Waters, Hellenic Centre for Marine Research, Athens-Sounio Av., Anavissos 19013, Greece.

(2) to get access to the full paper, use this link: Expanding the habitat quality assessment of rivers in Greece using an updated River Habitat Survey toolbox. Ecology and Hydrobiology (2024-07-25)

Online (and virtual) training on hydromorphology

Last week was a bit of a first for us and myself. We (the River Restoration Centre) held our first full day online hydromorphological training course with a virtual field work component!
Due to the Covid-19 outbreak, we have been unable to offer our usual series of training courses in person. The challenge here was to develop a course that provide the same kind of experience as the one we normally run that includes a very important field component where participants can directly experience hydromorphological processes and forms as well as pressures and impacts of modifications.


So we have been busy designing new ways of offering the same experience online by adding virtual site visits and even fieldwork. We delivered the Introduction to Hydromorphology (Level 1) training course using a combination of Zoom and Google Earth software. Fifteen delegates joined us on the Zoom call with regular switches to Google Earth and Streetview to demonstrate and experience hydromorphological processes forms and drivers virtually using one of our case study catchment on which we collected a lot of 360 photographs. Polls were set up to ask the delegates questions, and create as much of an interactive session as possible to keep everybody’s attention alive.

The crux of the course was to introduce delegates to a framework for analysing catchment and river processes, forms and how they are influenced by modifications and land management. This was achieved through formal short presentation followed by group work, in pairs, in the air and on virtual ground using Google Earth online, 360⁰ photos, and historic maps.

Delegates worked in pairs through tasks to spot features and modifications, think about processes, and map pressures. Finally, delegates were asked to assess everything we had gone over in the training and offer justified restoration options. This was a great opportunity to go over all the concepts we had been introduced to, and brainstorm ideas.

Feedback from the course has been really encouraging, and we are now looking at adapting the rest of our courses online and run more this Summer and Autumn. We are also considering adapting the River Habitat Survey course, potentially turning the existing presentations that are delivered in a training room into a series of online modules with virtual field work, and organising site visits separately over a few days to practice doing the survey whilst maintaining social distancing rules. We will be in touch with more information soon and we would welcome your suggestions.

In the meantime, please visit the RRC website to view our training events and please email us rrc@therrc.co.uk if you are interested in attending a virtual training course.

Using River Habitat Survey in the Geography Curriculum at the University of Worcester

by Professor Ian Maddock, University of Worcester, January 2020

Third year undergraduate students at the University of Worcester can take an optional module in River Conservation and Management as part of their Geography or Physical Geography degrees. We offer a practical-based degree programme with a strong emphasis on fieldwork and in this module, the practical work is focused around the use of RHS. The first half of the module is largely classroom-based, focusing on new approaches to environmentally-sensitive river management, including river restoration, natural flood management and the application of environmental flows.  Guest speakers from the EA, wildlife trusts, rivers trusts, local authorities and environmental consultancies provide an overview of some of the organisations involved with these topics and give students insights into potential careers relevant to their interests.

copyright Ian Maddock

RHS provides the focus for the 2nd half of the module. Students are familiarised with the field survey methods and features that are assessed in the classroom and then get to trial the software in a PC room with dummy data sets. This allows them to get used to data input and score calculation and explore the impact of altering input fields and assessing the effect on the metrics calculated. They get a feel for what influences the Habitat Quality Assessment (HQA) and the Habitat Modification Score (HMS) and their sensitivity to data input.

This is followed by three weeks of fieldwork using RHS. The first one involves a ‘practice’ survey of a local stream and then straight back into the computer room for data input and metric calculations. Students work in small groups (2s and 3s) and all assess the same reach. Comparing scores between groups and identifying which features were scored differently between them enables a discussion on observer variability and the need for training to help standardise approaches and optimise data quality. In the following two weeks students assess two contrasting sites. One is a largely natural gravel-bed stream in a local nature reserve, with minimal direct human impact and high habitat quality. The second is a contrasting, heavily-modified urban stream dominated by channelisation including weirs, bank and bed reinforcements and channel realignment. For their assignment, students are required to produce a mock consultancy report and use the RHS outputs to 1) assess the current habitat quality and habitat modification, and 2) make recommendations for the implementation of suitable river restoration techniques. The important thing with the latter is they use the breakdown of the HQA and HMS metrics to underpin their recommendations, explicitly acknowledging the output of the RHS survey results to justify the techniques proposed.

RHS provides an ideal field technique for this type of work for many reasons. Students can become proficient in its use relatively quickly, survey times are sufficiently short to enable them to conduct a survey in a 3-4 hour timetable slot, it promotes a discussion about how to identify river habitat features, what features are deemed ecologically relevant and how the differing importance of features is acknowledged by the differential weighting of them towards the calculated metrics, and how habitats have been impacted in the past or can be restored. It also enables a more general discussion on the use of rapid visual assessment methods as a survey protocol compared to more detailed but time consuming quantitative techniques. We plan to trial the new mobile app this forthcoming year which should provide a more convenient way of recording data in the field and uploading it to the PC-based software.

Professor Ian Maddock

Professor of River Science

University of Worcester

River Habitat Survey App

RRC in collaboration with the University of Trás-os-Montes and Alto Douro, have been working to create a new, free application to record River Habitat Survey (RHS) sites in the field, using your smartphone. It works on Android phones and tablets, and the simple interface makes it easy to input data similar to how you would have originally completed the paper form. Just work your way through the sections on the App, filling in information at each Spot Check, recording the number of riffles, pools and bars, before carrying out the Sweep Up assessment of the overall reach. The user can also take photographs to be added to the survey, and the data can be exported to the RHS Toolbox and RAPID2 software.

Download the RHS Mobile Android App (3.3 MB) : 

RHS App interface

RHS Natural Resources Wales analysis

Image result for nrw logoImage result for bournemouth universityImage result for river restoration centre

Natural Resources Wales, working with the River Restoration Centre and Bournemouth University, have recently published analysis of River Habitat Survey data from the repeat baseline survey in 2007-9 for six areas across Wales, allowing comparisons to be drawn in terms of levels of modifications and habitat quality. The analyses and indices from this report will be invaluable for Area Based Statements as well as providing evidence for our management and prioritisation of rivers. River restoration is a key priority for NRW and this report suggests a way forward for the assessment of restoration projects as well as modificaitions such as hydropower proposals.

Sue Hearn, Rivers Ecologist, Natural Resources Wales

View the report here

River Restoration Centre 19th Annual Network Conference 2018

Each year the River Restoration Centre (RRC) holds an Annual Network Conference that brings together professionals from all areas of river restoration including contractors, engineers, consultants, academics, and representatives from trusts, local organisations, and goverment agencies. The event is run over two days and includes around 50 speakers, workshop sessions and many other opportunities to network and make new contacts. Speakers present interesting, engaging presentations on their research or recent projects on current, hot topics.

For more information click here.

Books on rivers and river management

Rivers by Nigel Holmes and Paul Raven
Rivers_book_coverAn attractive new book by Nigel Holmes and Paul Raven should be a ‘must-read’ item for those with a professional, academic or general interest in rivers. Entitled simply ‘Rivers’ it is number 3 in the British Wildlife Collection series, and has 432 pages packed with more than 300 colour photographs, plus charts, graphs and other images. The sub-tilted theme is ‘a natural and not-so-natural history’ and the book describes how British rivers and associated plants, invertebrates, fish, birds and mammals have been changed by Nature and mankind since the last ice age.

It describes how and why these changes have occurred and explains how subtle variations in climate, geology and human history in different parts of Britain, have made each river unique. Three rivers, the Hampshire Meon, Welsh/Cheshire Dee and Endrick in Scotland are used to demonstrate how in more detail. The overall message is that understanding how rivers behave is crucial if they are to be properly managed and conserved for the benefit of people and wildlife into the future.
Copies can be ordered from British Wildlife Publishing (£30, free P&P within the UK) – details can be found here – and orders for signed copies taken by phoning 01865 811316.

Decision Support Systems: factors affecting their design and implementation within organisations. Lessons from two case studies by Marc Naura

DSS_book_Cover

How do we ensure that scientific tools, techniques and outputs (e.g. models, software, analytical techniques) are used in the ‘applied’ world’ of industry and government? In this research, we take the example of a group of software called Decision Support Systems (DSS) to discuss, with the help of literature reviews and 2 case studies, the factors affecting their implementation success within organisations. We particularly concentrate on the study of their interaction with organisational culture and the ‘frictions’ that assumptions taken in their design may generate with existing work practice and organisational beliefs. We further propose a methodology for developing models and tools that accounts for organisational and cultural factors, and demonstrate its application on a case study in a major public environmental organisation in the United Kingdom.

The book takes, as an example, the development of ToolHab, a Decision Support System for managing river habitats within the Environment Agency, England and Wales. ToolHab was originally designed for prioritising sites for habitat enhancement work for fish and it is now being tested for other purposes, such as the delivery of a environmental targets under the EU Water Framework Directive. The case studies illustrate the practical and cultural hurdles researchers, software designers and scientists face when attempting to develop methods, techniques and tools for practitioners and what can be done about it. The literature reviewed shows that these issues are by no means restricted to the environmental sector alone but are widespread across public and private industries whether in medicine, marketing or sales. Thus, the approach suggested will be relevant to many scientist, engineers and software developers involved in the production of tools and techniques across a wide spectrum of organisations (link to website).